For caregivers

Supporting Treatment Decision-Making and Advance Care Planning

As a caregiver, you may be on the front lines of very difficult medical decision-making processes — either supporting the patient as they make decisions, or (in the worst-case scenario) having to make decisions on their behalf. This guide helps you understand your role, support the ACP process, and prepare for the possibility of becoming a decision-making proxy.

2 min read · 6 sections · Updated 2026-04-19

Read in another language: Bahasa Indonesia中文

What matters most

Listen to the summary
  • Open the conversation about the patient's wishes gently and respectfully.
  • Document the patient's wishes and share them with the medical team and family.
  • As a proxy, decide based on the patient's wishes, not your own.
  • Seek emotional support if you feel burdened by decision-making.
  • If the family disagrees, refer back to the patient's wishes and ask the team for help.

Open the sections below for the full explanation.

01

Supporting the ACP Process

Initiating the Conversation

Sometimes patients are waiting for permission from family to discuss end-of-life wishes. You can open this door.

  • Start with: 'I'd like us to talk about what's most important to you in your care'
  • Convey that the goal is to honor their wishes
  • Choose a quiet and private time
  • Don't force it if they're not ready — give space and try again later

Questions That Can Help the Conversation

  • 'What is most important to you in your care?'
  • 'If your condition worsens, what would you most want to avoid?'
  • 'Where would you most want to be if your condition becomes critical?'
  • 'Who do you trust to make decisions if you cannot?'
  • 'Are there things you want to finish or say to someone?'

Document Their Wishes

  • Write down or record conversations about their wishes (with permission)
  • Help them write a letter or care preference document
  • Ensure all key family members are aware of these wishes
  • Share with the medical team and keep an easily accessible copy
02

Becoming a Decision-Making Proxy

If You Are Appointed as a Proxy

Being a medical proxy is a major responsibility requiring a deep understanding of the patient's values and wishes.

  • Ensure you truly understand the patient's wishes and values
  • Ask and clarify while the patient can still communicate
  • Document your discussions with the patient
  • Ask the medical team about the prognosis and available options

Guiding Principles as a Proxy

The main principle for a proxy is: make decisions based on what the patient would want (substituted judgment), not what you want for them.

  • Ask yourself: 'What would he/she choose if able?'
  • Separate your wishes from theirs
  • Consult with the palliative team and ethics consultation services if unsure
  • It's okay to feel uncertain — ask the medical team for help

Emotional Support for the Proxy

Making heavy medical decisions on behalf of a loved one can be deeply traumatic.

  • Seek support from a counselor or caregiver group after making a difficult decision
  • Remember: you are making the best decision with the information available
  • Feelings of doubt, guilt, or sadness afterward are normal
  • Consider bereavement support if the decision is followed by the patient's death
03

When Family Members Disagree

Family Conflict Regarding Medical Decisions

It is not uncommon for family members to disagree about treatment choices. This is one of the most stressful situations a family can face.

  • Always return to the patient's wishes as the main guide.
  • Request facilitation from the palliative care team or the hospital's social worker.
  • Consider an ethics consultation if the conflict is serious.
  • Remember that differing opinions often come from the same place: love.

Check your understanding

1. What can families do to start a conversation about the patient's end-of-life wishes?
2. If appointed as a decision-making proxy, what main principle should guide you?
3. When family members disagree about a medical decision, what is the main guidance?

Unsure? Ask the care team.

Frequently asked questions

How to talk about end-of-life care with a loved one?

Begin gently during a quiet time. Say, 'I'd like us to talk about what's most important to you in your care.' The goal is to honor their wishes. Don't force it if they're not ready, give them space and try again later. Questions like 'What would you want to avoid if your condition worsens?' can help the conversation flow.

What should I do if I am appointed to make medical decisions for a family member?

Being a proxy is a significant responsibility. Ensure you truly understand the patient's wishes and values by asking while they can still communicate. The main principle is to make decisions based on what the patient wants, not what you want for them. Ask yourself: 'What would they choose if they could?' and don't hesitate to ask the medical team for help if unsure.

What if my family disagrees about the care plan?

Family conflict over medical decisions is common and often stems from love. Always steer the conversation back to the patient's wishes as the primary guide. Don't hesitate to ask for facilitation help from the palliative team, hospital social workers, or the hospital's ethics consultation service to help resolve differences calmly.

I feel very guilty after making a difficult medical decision, is this normal?

Feeling doubtful, guilty, or sad after making a difficult medical decision is normal. Remember that you made the best decision with the information available. Seek support from a counselor or caregiver group after making a tough decision. If the decision is followed by the patient's death, consider bereavement support to help you process these heavy emotions.

Evidence transparency

Sources and clinical reading

This guide helps you prepare for a conversation; it does not replace the judgement of a doctor or therapist who knows your condition directly.

  1. 01NCCN Palliative Care Guidelines(opens the source site in a new tab)Palliative care guidance includes ACP.
  2. 02The Conversation Project(opens the source site in a new tab)A guide to starting an ACP conversation.