For patients

When Families Withhold Information: Understanding Collusion

Collusion occurs when family members ask the medical team not to tell the patient the true diagnosis or prognosis — usually to protect them. This is very common in Asian cultural contexts, including Indonesia. This guide helps you as a patient understand your rights and how to navigate this situation. This guide does not replace professional medical or ethical advice.

2 min read · 5 sections · Updated 2026-04-19

Read in another language: Bahasa Indonesia中文

What matters most

Listen to the summary
  • Collusion is when the family, and sometimes the medical team, agree not to tell the patient about their actual condition, such as the diagnosis or prognosis.
  • Collusion often occurs because families have good intentions to protect the patient from sadness.
  • Patients have the right to know their own health condition; it is a basic right.
  • Patients also have the right to choose NOT to know, but the decision must come from themselves.
  • If you suspect collusion, the patient can request a private conversation with the doctor to find out the true condition.

Open the sections below for the full explanation.

01

Understanding Collusion

What is Collusion?

In a medical context, collusion is when family members, and sometimes the medical team, agree not to tell the patient the truth about their condition — the diagnosis, prognosis, or other bad news.

  • Usually driven by good intentions: 'We don't want him/her to be sad or give up'
  • Very common in Asian cultures where the family is considered the primary decision-maker
  • However, collusion can isolate the patient and prevent them from making meaningful decisions about their own life

Your Rights as a Patient

  • You have the right to know your health condition — this is a basic patient right
  • You also have the right to choose NOT to know — but that choice must come from you yourself
  • Collusion that happens without your consent violates your autonomy as a patient
  • You can speak directly to the doctor: 'I want to know my true condition'

Check your understanding

1. What can I do if I suspect my family and doctor are hiding my condition?
2. What are my basic rights as a patient regarding health information?
3. If I choose not to know the details of the prognosis, what should I do?

Unsure? Ask the care team.

Frequently asked questions

What is collusion in patient care?

Collusion is when the family, and sometimes the medical team, agree not to tell the patient the true condition, such as the diagnosis or prognosis. This is often done with good intentions to protect the patient from sadness, especially in Asian cultures. However, collusion can isolate the patient and prevent them from making meaningful decisions about their own life. Collusion without the patient's consent also violates their autonomy.

What are my rights as a patient if my family is hiding my illness?

You have the basic right to know your own health condition. If you feel information is being withheld, you may request a private conversation with the doctor without family. Say clearly, "Doctor, please tell me my true condition." The decision to know or not know must come from you, not from the family.

What if I actually don't want to know the details of my illness?

That is also your right and must be respected. Communicate this choice clearly to the doctor and family. You can appoint a health proxy (e.g., a family member) who may receive information on your behalf. Ensure your proxy understands your values and wishes, so decisions made still align with your will.

When should I contact the palliative team immediately?

If you suspect collusion or difficulty discussing health conditions openly, immediately contact the palliative care team or a counselor. They can help facilitate difficult conversations between you, the doctor, and your family.

Evidence transparency

Sources and clinical reading

This guide helps you prepare for a conversation; it does not replace the judgement of a doctor or therapist who knows your condition directly.

  1. 01ABCDE Assessment: Truth-Telling Dilemmas 2024(opens the source site in a new tab)A guide to assessing truth-telling dilemmas in palliative care
  2. 02PubMed: Collusion in Palliative Care 2016(opens the source site in a new tab)Research on collusion in palliative care