For patients

Conflict Between Religious Belief and Medical Treatment

For many Indonesians, religious belief and spirituality are at the core of identity and the greatest source of strength. However, sometimes medical recommendations feel contradictory to religious beliefs — whether it's about certain types of treatment, refusal of blood transfusions, end-of-life decisions, or interpretations about 'fighting destiny'. This guide helps you navigate this tension with respect and wisdom.

3 min read · 6 sections · Updated 2026-04-19

Read in another language: Bahasa Indonesia中文

What matters most

Listen to the summary
  • Medical treatment and faith can go together as a gift from God.
  • Discuss any conflicts with a religious leader who understands medical issues.
  • Communicate your religious beliefs openly to the medical team.
  • Mentally competent adult patients have the right to refuse treatment, including on the basis of religious belief
  • Spirituality can be a source of strength in facing illness.

Note: If refusing treatment carries a high risk of death, make sure you have received complete information about that risk from the medical team.

Open the sections below for the full explanation.

01

Common Tensions

Examples of Frequent Conflicts

  • Belief that healing comes only from God — does seeking medical treatment mean having less faith?
  • Refusal of medical procedures due to specific religious beliefs
  • Tension between 'fighting to the very end' vs. 'accepting destiny with sincerity'
  • Concerns about medications containing ingredients prohibited by religion
  • Conflict between end-of-life decisions and religious principles about life

You Don't Have to Choose

In many religious traditions, medical treatment and faith are not contradictory — both are seen as means provided by God to help humans.

  • Islam: seeking treatment is considered an obligation, not a sign of lacking tawakal (trust in God)
  • Christianity: many theologians view medical science as a gift from God
  • Consult specific interpretations with your trusted religious leader
  • A good palliative care team respects and integrates the spiritual dimension
03

Integrating Faith and Treatment

Spirituality as a Source of Strength

Even when there is tension, spirituality can be a great source of strength in facing serious illness.

  • Maintain worship practices adjusted to your condition
  • Ask for prayers from your religious community
  • Read or listen to sacred texts that provide comfort
  • Connect with religious communities for practical and emotional support

Example of an Integrated Perspective

Many religious scholars offer perspectives that integrate faith and medical science:

  • The doctor is the instrument — God is the healer (a common perspective in Islam and Christianity)
  • Caring for the body entrusted by God is an act of worship
  • Accepting palliative care can be a form of gratitude for the gift of life
  • Refusing unnecessary treatment is different from refusing all care

Check your understanding

1. What should be done before making a treatment decision based on religious beliefs?
2. How should one communicate with the medical team regarding religious beliefs that affect care decisions?
3. In Islam, what is the view on seeking medical treatment?

Unsure? Ask the care team.

Frequently asked questions

Does seeking medical treatment mean having less faith in God?

No. In many religious traditions, medical treatment and faith are not in conflict. In Islam, seeking treatment is considered an obligation, not a sign of lacking trust in God. In Christianity, many theologians view medical science as a gift from God. From a perspective common in both Islam and Christianity, doctors are seen as instruments, while God is the one who heals.

How to refuse treatment for religious reasons?

Openly share your religious beliefs with the medical team. Every mentally competent adult patient has the right to refuse treatment, including on the basis of religious belief. The medical team must respect this right and ensure you understand the consequences of such a refusal. You can formally document this wish in an Advance Care Directive.

When should you immediately contact the medical team in case of a religious conflict?

Contact the medical team immediately if treatment refusal poses a serious risk to the patient's life. The medical team must provide complete information about these risks. Also, do not hesitate to ask a spiritual care provider or hospital chaplain to help mediate between medical needs and your religious beliefs.

How to seek religious support during serious illness?

Maintain worship practices suitable for your condition, ask for prayers from your religious community, and read comforting sacred texts. Contact your religious community for practical and emotional support. You can also ask the medical team to connect you with a religious leader who understands bioethical issues and modern medicine.

Evidence transparency

Sources and clinical reading

This guide helps you prepare for a conversation; it does not replace the judgement of a doctor or therapist who knows your condition directly.

  1. 01Majelis Ulama Indonesia — Fatwa Kedokteran(opens the source site in a new tab)Medical fiqh guidelines from MUI
  2. 02NCCN Distress Management — Spiritual Concerns(opens the source site in a new tab)Clinical guidelines for spiritual support